Project Public Input Process
The goal of the VTrans On-Road Bicycle Plan is to improve the condition of state roads to enhance safety and better accommodate the needs of all bicyclists - families, commuters and recreational riders. This will be achieved by developing an improvement plan that identifies opportunities to enhance bicycle conditions on state roads designated as the highest priority bicycle corridors. The Plan will also help prioritize VTrans investment decisions while balancing limited resources.
The priority bicycle corridors are defined as state roads with the highest current and potential use by bicyclists.
VTrans is currently in Phase 1 of the project. The goal of Phase 1 is to categorize the state roads into high-, moderate- and low-use corridors based on current and potential use as illustrated in the Draft VTrans Bicycle Corridor Priority Map (formerly called the Draft Desirability Map). For a description of later project phases see FAQ #2.
VTrans anticipates the project will include three phases, with Phase 1 concluding (see Phase 1 description in FAQ #1) Fall 2015/Winter 2016. Once Phase 1 has concluded, we will begin to further define the scope of the subsequent phases.
Phase 1 gathers data and public input to create the VTrans Bicycle Corridor Priority Map categorizing state roads into high-, moderate- and low-use corridors based on current and potential bicycle use.
Phase 2 will examine safety data entered in the Phase 1 interactive crowdsourcing map by the public (aka Wikimap) and analyze reported bicycle crashes and identify critical gaps in the condition of the high priority corridors as shown on the VTrans Bicycle Corridor Priority Map.
Phase 3 will identify improvement strategies to address the gaps identified in Phase 2.
Public involvement will be sought throughout all phases of the project.
No. The information we are collecting is focused on State-managed roads and segments of town highways that function as an extension of State roads (also known as Class 1 Town Highways). Some state-managed roads that are limited access were included such as VT- 289 and the St. Albans State Highway because a suitable adjacent alternative bicycle facility does not exist in those locations.
The data collected for this project includes Class 1 Town Highways (those road segments of town highways functioning as an extension of State roads) as part of Phase 1 methodology. This information is available to municipalities for their use and will be consulted during Class Town 1 Highways projects.
- Current Use
- where cyclists are riding now
- Potential Use
- where cyclists would ride if conditions were improved
- where cyclists have greatest potential to ride given land use patterns
- Current Use
The VTrans Bicycle Corridor Priority Map (formerly called the Draft Desirability Map) is the culmination of Phase 1 and will be used to help prioritize improvements and maintenance activities by VTrans on state roads. The high-, moderate- and low-use corridors on the map represent state roads based on an analysis of current and potential bicycle use. A high-use corridor is a higher priority corridor for improvements. The map will also be used to inform future phases of the project (see future phases description in FAQ #2).
It is important to note, VTrans will continue to incorporate bicycle-friendly improvements in all projects and maintenance activities however, high use corridors defines where VTrans will focus efforts.
The VTrans Bicycle Corridor Priority Map shows current and potential bicycle use on state roads. Bicycle use was quantified through analysis of land use patterns, bicycle access to state roads, proximity to destinations, data collected on recreational bicycling, and 2,100+ users providing public input through the project’s interactive crowdsourcing map (aka WikiMap*).
*The interactive crowdsourcing map is part of the development of the VTrans On Road Bicycle Plan. VTrans used this crowdsourcing tool to gather information from the public about current and potential bicycle use. This was captured by asking users to select a line type when mapping a ride. The line types included:
- State Road I like to Bike
- State Road I bike but could be improved
- State road I’d like to use, but needs improvement
Transportation and recreation are different bicycle trip purposes and are equally important measures in determining current and potential bicycle use of a roadway.
Transportation refers to the dominant purpose of a trip being utilitarian, such as doing errands, commuting to work or school, or visiting a friend.
Recreation refers to the dominant purpose of a bicycling trip being for exercise or enjoyment of the outdoors.
There is much crossover between transportation and recreation bicycling, sometimes even on a single ride. However, we distinguish the two because travel behavior, preferred routes, and appropriate facility types can be different.
VTrans captured recreational riding using both Strava data and the interactive crowdsourcing map (aka Wikimap).
Strava Metro is a mobile application used by bicyclists to track recreational and transportation bicycling trips.
WikiMap is an interactive crowdsourcing map to crowdsource information from the public about current and potential bicycle use.
Yes. Strava relies on GPS (global positioning systems), which works worldwide regardless of cellular service.
Are transportation bicycling (commuter/utilitarian) trips included in the VTrans Bicycle Corridor Priority Map?
VTrans captured transportation bicycling trips through the interactive crowdsourcing map (aka WikiMap) and by analyzing land use patterns, bicycle access to state roads, and proximity to destinations.
The term ‘desirability’ was intended to describe the potential and current bicycle use on state roads: where people ride and where they would ride if conditions were improved. To clarify the purpose of the map, VTrans will now use the term ‘use’ rather than ‘desirability’ to indicate current and potential bicycle use.
Current and potential bicycle use along corridors was determined by the following data sources:
Due to the nature of the raw data source and the scoring methodology used to determine bicycle use, some sections along a road segments/corridors needing smoothing. VTrans undertook a smoothing exercise to introduce consistency in a corridor where appropriate. The “smoothing” exercise used our with and experience managing state roads along with the following considerations:
- Blend very small segments with adjacent segments
- Use logical connections or terminus
- intersections with major state or local roads
- roads known to be a suitable alternative to a state route
- roads known as a popular route with bicyclist
- Significant land use changes
- Municipal boundary or City limits
- existing school or recreation area, etc.
- Resort or significant trip generators
- tourist destinations
- four season resort
- International or State border crossings
- Designated Scenic Byway, Rail Trail or existing signed bicycle route
Because VTrans methodology relied on land use patterns, population inherently affects the potential use of state roads for bicycles.
In response to concerns that density was favored in the methodology, we refined our scoring system so the maximum number of points a segment could receive from land use pattern-based riding and from recreation riding are the same.
Safety is very important to VTrans, and the overarching goal of this project is to ensure safer roads for all users.
We implicitly received safety information in Phase 1 using the interactive crowdsourcing map by asking users to draw lines on state roads they “would like to use but need improvement.” See FAQ #2 for interactive crowdsourcing map input.
Future phases will include an analysis of reported bicycle crashes and examine the safety data entered in the Phase 1 interactive crowdsourcing map (aka Wikimap).
Yes. Although we do not anticipate having this data available until Spring 2016.
Contact VTrans Planning Coordinator Sommer Bucossi at firstname.lastname@example.org
Public input for Phase 1 included:
- Collection of Strava data for 10,459 users
- Interactive crowdsourcing map (aka Wikimap) input from 2,123 users
- Two Statewide Public Meetings using VIT technology and broadcast to the web with attendance of 66 participants at meeting #1 and 51 participants at meeting #2.
- A stakeholder committee that included representatives from Regional Planning Commissions, Tourism & Marketing, Agency of Commerce & Community Development, Vermont Bike & Pedestrian Coalition / Local Motion, VBT Bicycling & Walking Vacations, Green Mountain Bicycle Club, American Council of Engineering Consultants
- A dedicated email address (Vermontbike@gmail.com) for project comments that received 144 email correspondences
- The VTrans On Road Bicycle Plan project website that included:
- Archived videos of both statewide public meetings
- Key project information
- Project materials were provided to state libraries throughout Vermont to post statewide public meeting information on their bulletin boards and social media pages.
Yes, public input will be sought at all stages of the VTrans On-Road Bicycle Plan, and all future phases of the project will involve multiple chances for the public to engage in the process.
Concluding of Phase 1 involves a 4th Stakeholder group (October 28, 2015), updating the project website, holding a Statewide VIT Meeting Tuesday December 1st before finalizing the Phase 1 report and Draft VTrans Bicycle Corridor Priority Map.
Through winter/spring of 2016, VTrans will begin to define the scope of the subsequent phases.
Phase 2 will examine safety data entered in the Phase 1 interactive crowdsourcing map (aka Wikimap) and analyze reported bicycle crashes and identify critical gaps in the condition of the corridors as shown on the VTrans Bicycle Corridor Priority Map.
Phase 3 will identify improvements to be considered to address the gaps identified in Phase 2.
Public involvement will be sought throughout all phases of the project.